Simpler networks. Smaller bills.

ServicesHow we get paidBuckeye CareResultsBlogToolsRefer a businessAboutContactNo charge for a bill auditBook a call614-224-2003
Home / Services / Advisor vs MSP

Telecom Broker vs MSP for Business Phones and Internet

A telecom broker shops and compares the carriers that can serve your building, then helps you pick one. An MSP runs your network and IT day to day after it is set up.

Rings Jonathan and the team 24x7.

MSP deliversHelpdesk, endpoints, patching, SOC. You pay them for that team.
Advisor does notNo products of our own. We place best-of-breed partners, including managed IT providers, and stay accountable.
Often bothWe frequently work alongside the MSP a client already has.

We compare prices from 400+ providers and platforms.

AT&TVerizonLumenSpectrumComcastCoxT-MobileFrontierZayoCogentRingCentralNextiva8x8ZoomMicrosoft TeamsWebex
The short version.

A managed service provider delivers the service. An advisor helps you choose who does.

They run your helpdesk, monitor your endpoints, patch your servers, staff a SOC. They have engineers, tooling and a delivery team, and you pay them for that team.

An advisor doesn't run your network. We carry no products of our own. We place best-of-breed partners, including managed IT providers with their own engineers, and hold them to the contract. What we do is know the market, compare it honestly for you, find the right provider at the right price, read the contract before you sign it, and stay responsible for how it turns out.

Buckeye Telecom is a telecom broker. We have agreements with all of the network providers and can supply a list quickly.

The two are not competitors. An MSP is a supplier you might need us to help you choose. We frequently work alongside the MSP a client already has, and we have talked clients out of replacing one.

Compared

The actual distinction.

Technology advisorManaged service provider
What they sellJudgment and market accessDelivered technical service
Who employs the engineersNobody, we have noneThey do
Who you payThe provider, directlyThe MSP, directly
How they are paidResidual from the provider you chooseYour monthly fee
Product incentiveNone, no products of our ownUsually a stack they have standardized on
Whose name is on the contractYours, with the underlying providerUsually theirs, with you as the customer
What they do when it breaksOpen and drive the ticket, escalate the providerFix it
BreadthThe whole market, every providerWhat they support
Why the incentive difference matters

Standardizing isn't dishonest, but it still points you one way

An MSP that has standardized on a security stack has a good reason to recommend that stack. That is not dishonesty, standardization is how they deliver consistently and keep costs sane, but it does mean the recommendation and the commercial interest point the same way.

Our incentive is different, not absent. We are paid a residual by whichever provider you choose. For any given service that rate is closely matched from provider to provider, so there is very little to steer toward. And because a residual only continues while you stay, putting you somewhere wrong costs us the entire stream at renewal, considerably worse for us than any difference in rate.

Ask both of us the same question: what do you make if I buy this? You should get a straight answer from either. If you do not, that tells you something.

Which one you need, and when.

Usually the answer is both, at different moments.

01

You need an MSP

When you need work performed, helpdesk, monitoring, patching, incident response, someone on-site. No advisor can do this for you, and any advisor who says otherwise is reselling somebody else's team.

02

You need an advisor

When you are choosing between providers, opening or closing locations, facing a renewal, or cannot get a straight comparison because every vendor is quoting a different shape of thing.

03

You need both

The common case at multi-site scale. The MSP delivers; we source what they deliver on, hold the renewal calendar and escalate the carriers they cannot.

When you should not use an advisor

Read this section. It is the point of the page.

If you have a single location and one internet circuit, you do not need us. Call the two carriers that serve your building, take the better price, and put the renewal date in your calendar. That is a thirty-minute job and hiring anyone to do it is theatre.

If you already have a competitive comparison in hand and someone on staff who reads contracts carefully, you can do this yourself. Most companies don't have that, which is why they use us. The work itself isn't a mystery.

And if what you need is someone to run your network day to day, you need an MSP, not us. We can help you pick one, but that's a different job, and if you only need the day-to-day work, go straight to them. If you want the wider picture of outsourcing IT, phones and security, see what outsourcing looks like.

Common questions.

Including whether one company can be both

Can one company be both?
Yes, and many are. Just be clear which hat is on when a recommendation is made, and ask what they earn on it either way.
Does using an advisor cost more than going direct?
No. The provider pays us out of their own margin; your price is the same as going direct. Nobody adds a line to your invoice for us.
Will our MSP see this as a threat?
Some do at first. Most stop once it is clear we are not bidding for their work, we are sourcing the circuits and platforms underneath it, which is the part they usually do not want to own.
Who do we call when something is down?
For anything the MSP delivers, call the MSP. For carrier and provider faults, call us and we will drive it.

Ask both of us what we make if you buy this.

You should get a straight answer from either. If you do not, that tells you something.

Book a call